4) After Middle Earth: Pegrioc

Eoborn stared at Freesia, confused, who was looking quite terrified. “You alright?” he asked her.

“I…uh…who do you have in mind to go with you?” she asked, worrying he might say her.

“Well, I was actually under the impression that I should ask you to come with me.” Oh dear! Her worries had come true. She struggled to come up with an answer when he spoke again. “I feel that your knowledge of Middle Earth history would be quite useful and wise to have with me. I realize it sounds quite terrifying, but all I need from you is your mind.”

My mind? she thought, I’m just a girl! How can I bring anything to his journey that he can’t get from a man? I only just came of age a decade ago. Forty-four years is not very old in hobbit years. 

“I’m unsure. My family is back in the Shire, I don’t know how they would feel about this. I should really run it by them first.” Freesia looked down at her feet.

“Aren’t you quite old enough to make your own decisions?” he asked her.

“Well, somewhat. I am only forty-four and I am a girl.” she thought her answer was quite understandable, but his answer surprised her.

“Forty-four is perfectly old enough to go out on your own!” he said as if he was surprised at her answer, “I myself am only fifty. That is young for an elf-Dunedain hybrid.” he smiled.

Fifty? That is how old Frodo was. But I am still a girl. Girls don’t adventure, they stay home and take care of the family. Eowyn is the only exception. 

“Well, I don’t know why you would want a girl to come with you, but I suppose I could join you if that is what you really want.” she said, still hesitant to get into an adventure she had no way of knowing she would survive. She didn’t even know what exactly they would do to get the throne back.

“Great! Now, obviously we can’t take back Gondor just the two of us. I don’t suppose you know of any other hobbits that would like to join us? Maybe we can find a dwarf to join us.” Freesia could only think of one person that would like to join them.

Pegrioc.

Pegrioc was a descendant to Merriadoc “Merry” Brandybuck, a distant relative to Freesia. Peregrin “Pippin” Took had a son who married Sam’s daughter. Merry and Pippin were distant cousins. Thus making Freesia and Pegrioc distant relatives, which isn’t very strange, almost all hobbits are distant relatives.

Pegrioc was very much like Pippin. Reckless, unintelligent, sarcastic and hilarious. It was quite attractive in Freesia’s eyes, though she couldn’t admit it to anyone but her inner thoughts.

“I do know of one hobbit that would enjoy the journey, but I’m not quite certain how beneficial to the purpose of this adventure.” Freesia told Eoborn.

“Well, more is always better. I couldn’t care if he was just there for the sake of the credit, having more people along with us will make the journey bearable. I am certain we will find others who would love to join us.”

Freesia wasn’t sure if she wanted to be excited or terrified. She had always dreamed of going along on Frodo’s adventure, but now that she had the opportunity, she couldn’t decide.

Well, for now they just needed to worry about inviting Pegrioc along without the Scars deciding to join them first.

In that moment, Freesia suddenly realized something inconsistent about Eoborn’s story. Orcrist was supposed to be buried with Thorin. Only a sick villain would dig up the king of Erebor for the sake of getting his sword.

What was she getting herself into?!

Top Hobbit Moments

Well, you heard the top moments from the Lord of the Rings, now it’s time for the top moments from the Hobbit! As we all well know, the Hobbit movies weren’t up to their potential, but that does not mean they weren’t good movies.

For those who are strange and have not yet seen the movies or read the book, there are some spoilers ahead.

10:  Thorin’s farewell

bofa

Yet another moment made great thanks to brilliant acting. Martin Freeman did absolutely FANTASTIC with his acting as Thorin is dying. Straight away we see his denial of the situation. He tries desperately to save him, reassuring him that he will live because the eagles have come to save them. He had gone far past hope and was now just in denial. This is acting!

9: Bilbo encounters Smaug

bilbosmaug

Everyone has got to love when Smaug has his conversation with Bilbo. Almost word for word from the book! Benedict Cumberbatch’s voice was so brilliantly used to create the voice of the dragon. Everyone loves a good dragon, as it was once said, “it’s simply not an adventure worth telling if there aren’t any dragons.”

Fun Fact: Benedict Cumberbatch memorized the entire dialogue of Smaug from the book and voice acted it through twice, whilst wearing the motion capture suit and crawling around like a lizard (Komodo dragon specifically).

8: Thunder battle

stonegiants

I love this scene because of how cool and intense it looks. It is cool to see what rock giants might look like, thinking of them as if they are actual beings, not just people made of rock. The CGI at this part is one of the only parts that was done well with the animation (the other stuff did not need to be animated).

7: That’s what Bilbo Baggins hates

bilbohates

This song was a commodity that I just thought was necessary. I love to see things added word for word from the book. This song was also up beat and entertaining to follow. I especially love when Bofur is bumping around dishes with his elbow as he is playing his flute. Tolkien had so many songs, it’s obvious he loved music, so it is essential that that is portrayed in his book’s movie adaptation.

6: Misty Mountains song

hobbitsong

Another song that was necessary. I love love love this song! All the deep voices of these men put together with perfect wording and feeling. This is a song that gets the listener to think about the words, and if you don’t at the beginning, when you look back at it afterward, it is pretty much a summary of their journey to be.

5: Thorin’s Dragon sickness

thorinbofayes

Of all the things that Tolkien wanted to portray with his stories, this is one of the most important. Tolkien was all about symbolism, and with Thorin’s dragon sickness, which we see more clearly with the Balrog in Moria, he was trying to show what greed and temptation does to a person. When Thorin says the exact same thing Smaug said, with Smaug’s voice at the same time, it is super cool. It is interesting to see how all that treasure corrupted even the most noble of dwarves.

4: Bilbo comes back

bilbocomesback

The scene right after the goblin tunnels, when Thorin thinks Bilbo left, is a great scene. I love Bilbo’s little speech about how he does miss his old life and how he realizes that he doesn’t fit in, but what matters is that he is willing to fight with them to win back their home, where they fit in. It is cool to see that even though Bilbo is small and somewhat wimpy, he has the courage to do the right thing and help other.

3: Gollum

bilbo-and-gollum

I almost would leave this section saying, “nuff said,” but it deserves more than that. I love Gollum. Especially thanks to Andy freaking amazing Serkis. His work with Gollum is just pure talent. Everyone loves the scene with Gollum and his riddles. To hear so many done word for word as well was great.

2: Thorin’s acceptance 

bilboandthorin

I know I’m not alone when I say I was so angry at Thorin when he gets up after being saved by eagles and starts talking to Bilbo. We were all almost certain he was legitimately angry at Bilbo for his act of courage. I was almost in tears when Thorin admits he was wrong and gives Bilbo a hug. I was so happy. You could see they had formed a friendship that would last longer than their life times. To admit your fault, especially as a king, takes a huge amount of courage.

And to go right along with this is when Bilbo saves Thorin’s life. You just want to jump out of your seat and cheer him on. I was so happy when this happened. Such a small guy taking on a huge, purely evil orc. Amazing!

1: Bard’s encounter with Smaug

bain

I have to say this was my all time favorite scene. The acting in this scene was perfect! When Bard’s bow breaks, and his son had just come to give him the black arrow, and Bard has to balance the arrow on Bain’s shoulder! Bain’s acting was so perfect! The fear that you could almost feel through his acting as he can hear a huge, deadly dragon coming right toward him. And Bard, you can see how much he loves his son and cares for him. And looking at his son right in front of him as he is preparing to kill the dragon makes you realize that he knows exactly who he is doing this for, he is staring right at the reason!

This was the scene that made me love Bard and Bain! I just love them! They became my favorite characters through one short scene. Their acting was just amazing!

No matter what anyone says, these movies were good. They weren’t 100% accurate, but we already should know that it’s impossible for that to happen. The actors that were chosen provided for an amazing trilogy thanks to their wonderful acting talents. Don’t let the negative critics get you down, these movies are so great!

Top Lord of the Rings Moments

I recently saw a few blogs about the top Middle Earth moments, but was slightly disappointed with them. Yes, they had some good ones, but they left out some of the best parts and the reasons why they are the best. So, I decided to write the best parts of Lord of the Rings and why, mostly regarding the brilliant acting!

11: Gandalf vs. the Balrog

gandalf

Everyone knows the line that happens at this point of the Lord of the Rings movies. We’ve heard tons of jokes and seen tons of memes regarding Gandalf’s line “You shall not pass!” What makes this part so great? Personally, I think this part of the movie is Ian McKellan’s best scene containing his best acting. When he shouts that line, you can feel its power. It’s as if you are there in that moment, in Frodo’s place, witnessing it.

10: Boromir’s death

boromirdeath

This scene contains a lot of character building elements in it for a few different characters. I literally don’t understand why some people hate Boromir so much, it was temptation, it was his fatal flaw, but it did not make him a villain. When he speaks his last words, you see his true honor. It’s amazing he has any honor with a father like his. He was corrupted by what his father wanted.

In this scene, we also see Legolas’ reaction to death. He seems to be confused, looking at Boromir wondering what is happening. He never understood death and how it affects people when it’s someone they care about. Also, Aragorn is characterized even more so than before. We see his true kingliness come out.

9: Eomer finds Eowyn on the battlefield

eomer

This scene has always been one of THE best scenes in the entire trilogy. Karl Urban does some breathtakingly amazing acting. When he finds his sister, thinking she is dead, his cries of pain and despair are so heart wrenching it’s as if my own sister has died. His acting is just so brilliant! The look on his face when this happens is painful.

8: Hiding from the black rider

rider

This scene is the spark that starts the painful burden Frodo has to carry. As Sauron’s servant is so close, almost touching them, Frodo feels the evil temptation of the ring. He almost puts it on, if it weren’t for his friends by his side. When we see the bugs crawling out and running away because of the ring wraith, it makes you feel almost exactly like the hobbits feel. If even the nasty, crawly little bugs are running from this guy, that is not a good sign. This is also when Merry understands somewhat what is going on.

7: Pippin’s song

pippinsong

This scene has some major character changing elements in it. Pippin used to be a care free, not very smart hobbit. He didn’t understand the danger they were in, he didn’t understand why Frodo had to leave, or why he had to leave his closest friend to go to Minas Tirith. When he is before the father of the man who desperately tried to save his life, resulting in his death, all the understanding and emotion hits him. And this is why he volunteers to work for Denethor.

His character deepens the most in the scene with his song, because he has seen Denethor send Faramir off to his death, not even caring. It breaks Pippin’s heart. As Faramir and his soldiers are riding off toward Osgiliath, Pippin sings a song that basically explains the entire movie’s tone. The words touch my heart every time, not to mention how great of a singer Billy Boyd is! The whole thing is wonderful!

6: Sam’s speech 

sam

Yet another part of the Lord of the Rings trilogy that everyone knows. Frodo has almost given up and Gollum has returned into Smeagol’s mind. Everything seems to be over and all hope seems to be lost. They were so close to Mordor and then they were taken to Osgiliath. Sam has to convince Frodo that it’s not over. They can’t give up and they WILL make it to the volcano. He does the one thing he can, he tells Frodo what they are holding on to that is keeping them going.

5: “The way is shut”

ghostking

The scene when Aragorn is trying to get the ghosts to serve their last duty in order to be freed is one that a lot of people think is strange. The fact that there are ghosts causes some people to not be sure how they feel about the movies. For some reason, ghosts put people off.

Nonetheless, this scene is a great one. Aragorn becomes so much more powerful and intimidating when he blocks the ghost’s attack with his sword. The ghost king’s reaction to the remade blade is almost funny, because he is so surprised. Yet, in order to keep himself just as threatening, the ghost king fades away, laughing. Which is yet another cool scene.

4: The beacons are lit

beacons

Again, another scene that is great thanks to Howard Shore’s brilliant music. I love watching, goosebumps forming, as each beacon lights and the music builds up. It’s great.

3: “No parent should have to bury their child.”

theoden

Yet another scene that is great thanks to brilliant acting. When Theoden is finally freed from Sauruman’s control, he finds out that his son died. Just the death of a child alone would break a man, but it is even worse as he realizes that he was not there for his son in his last moments, he didn’t even care because he was being controlled.

When Theoden says this line, and he begins to cry, it is yet another emotional scene that is so powerful. You can feel his emotions. Imagining being in his place, it becomes even more real.

2: The company is formed

Fellowship

The whole part of the first movie, from the forming of the fellowship up to the beginning of their journey is amazing. The hilarious moment when the three uninvited hobbits pop in. Pippin’s stupidity at the situation. It’s all great, but what makes this so amazing is when they, one by one, walk over the hill, the awesome music playing behind them, it’s just great. Music is one of the most powerful tools in provoking emotion.

1: Ride now!

death

It is no secret that this is almost the best part of all the movies. The power in Theoden’s speech is amazing. As he shouts those words, that will always be stuck in my mind, you just want to stand up and start shouting, “DEATH!” It’s almost disturbing…but anyone who has seen it should understand. It is so amazing.

0: Bilbo wants the ring

bilbowantshisring

I put this on here as zero, simply because it is not necessarily a great scene, it’s just hilarious and terrifying at the same time. When Bilbo reaches for the ring and his face turns into an almost Gollum-like face, you want to scream and then laugh your head off. I think everyone is in agreement that this is the scariest part of the entire trilogy.

Obviously, there are many many more great scenes throughout these movies, and don’t think I like any of the movie less than it deserves. The entire thing is amazing, and all the tiniest scenes affect me in different ways. Each character has their share of characterizing mastery, thanks to Peter Jackson and Howard Shore.

Honestly, I don’t really care what anyone now thinks of Peter Jackson after the Hobbit trilogy, he is still amazing and he did what he had to do in order to make amazing movies and form Tolkien’s brilliant literature into a reality. Middle Earth might as well be real, now that you can go and visit many of the areas that are now known as Middle Earth in New Zealand.

The Lord of the Rings will always be the best movie in the universe.

3) After Middle Earth: Orcrist

Freesia began to panic, thinking about the orcish man she had seen. She knew from Frodo’s story what it meant when a sword glowed blue. But Sting is still in the possession of the Shire. The only other swords she knew of that could glow were Orcrist and Glamdring. Glamdring was Gandalf’s sword and Orcrist was Thorin Oakenshield’s.

Who was this man and whose sword does he have?

The man noticed Freesia looking at him and immediately jumped up. Freesia worried that he had seen the look of recognition on her face and would come after her. He began to walk, she couldn’t see where he was going because he slipped into the crowd. She started to walk back to the innkeeper, hoping she would be able to go to her room before the man caught her.

She was only half way there when she felt a hand on her shoulder. She jumped. Turning around, she saw that it was the man. He grabbed her shoulder and pulled her along with him toward a back hallway.

Once they were out of earshot to the lobby, the man lifted off his hood. This was far too much like Frodo’s story to be a coincidence. The man’s hair was very unusual. It was cut very short, so short Freesia wasn’t sure how he got it that way. It was no wonder he wore a hood. Freesia noticed that there was just the slightest point in the man’s ears. Not enough to be anything but a man, but men don’t have ears like that.

“Who are you?” they both asked simultaneously.

Freesia spoke first, “What do you mean ‘who am I,’ you are the one who dragged me back here. I’m just a simple hobbit that is stopping by for the night.” The man was surprised at her aggressiveness.

“Well, how ’bout you tell me how you recognized my blade?” he said. Freesia wasn’t sure how to answer. So she just went ahead and told the truth.

“I read about it. My ancestor, Samwise Gamgee had a book that was written by Frodo and Bilbo Baggins about their adventures. Bilbo saw that blade, although I’m not sure which one it is.”

“Orcrist.” he said almost automatically.

“How do you have it?” Freesia asked.

“I do believe that is not your business.” he said.

do believe that my recognition of the blade is not yours.” she retorted.

“Very well. If you must know it came to me by my ancestor’s good friend. It was given to him by his relative, Dain Ironfoot, who inherited it from Thorin Oakenshield.” Freesia became excited about the matter. This, too, was suspected by the man.

“Oh dear, how delightful! I had always wanted to see the relics of the stories for my own eyes! Would you mind if I had a look at it?” she said.

The man was slightly taken aback. Nonetheless, he unsheathed the blade and let Freesia have a look.

“Oh wow! It is just as Old Bilbo had described! Oh how I wish I could have met the old hobbit, he passed Old Took, you know, who had once been the hobbit that lived longer than any other. Of course, he did have the ring that made him live longer and he–”

“Ring? What ring?” he asked.

“Oh, you must know the tale of how Frodo Baggins destroyed the One Ring to rule them all!” she said.

“Yes, of course I do. But you must tell me about this old Bilbo. I had heard the tale of the ring’s destruction, but how did this hobbit fellow come by it?”

Surely he couldn’t be serious! She had thought.

“Well! Bilbo Baggins found the ring while trapped in the goblin kingdom in the Misty Mountains! While down there, an odd little creature called Gollum threatened to eat the poor hobbit. They had a game of riddles, and thanks to that little trinket, or so he had called it at the time, Bilbo won the riddle game. Gollum did not like this, however, and he betrayed their deal, which was for Gollum to lead Bilbo out of the caves. When he ran off, he tripped and the ring slipped onto his finger, causing him to disappear! And that is how Old Gandalf discovered that the “trinket” was actually the One Ring of power!”

“You are quite smart for a small thing, aren’t you?” he said.

“Pardon me, but I take offense to that!” she said. Again the man looked taken aback. “Wait a moment, if that blade is glowing, that should mean an orc is nearby!” Freesia exclaimed. “But all the orcs were destroyed. How can that be glowing?”

“Have you not heard? If you have not heard, surely you have seen the creatures that have been wandering about.” he said.

“Of course!” Freesia said, “What was that awful thing? It chased me all the way here to Bree! I had been worried Bree was no longer a hospitable place.”

“Those are not orcs. They are Scars.”

“Yes, I have heard the term.”

“Scars are like orcs in only one way. They were tortured to become what they are now. Only, they weren’t once elves, they were once men. That is why I am here. If men are being tortured, then that means there is an evil on this earth that is creating monsters of my people. Or my ancestor’s people I should say.”

“You keep going on about your ancestors. Who are they?” Freesia asked.

“Well, my name is Eoborn. My ancestor is Aragorn, son of Arathorn. This is why my ears are pointed slightly. He did marry an elf, after all.”

“Oh! That is marvelous! To think that I would ever meet a descendant of the great king Aragorn! And that you are related to Elrond as well! It must be a lovely title to have!”

“It would seem so. However, I fear there is evil in the heart of Gondor. Had things gone rightly, I would have been king of Gondor. But seeing as I am part elf, the people of Gondor suddenly decided to make a purely man royal line. They didn’t want any elf mixed in. I don’t see how this is a problem, seeing as I hold the last bit of elf to ever walk the earth. I don’t see how I could have been a threat to the royal line.”

“How terrible!” Freesia said, “That does indeed sound as though someone is desperately grasping for the throne. Perhaps you are right about there being evil there. Only a man hungry for power would be so desperate to do such a thing.”

“That gives me a great deal of reassurance to know I am not the only one to think so. Even if you are just a little hobbit girl.” Freesia raised an eyebrow at him, who smiled ever so slightly.

“If this is the problem, why are you here? You said that that is what led you here.” Freesia asked.

“It’s funny you, of all people to run in to, mention this. I too had read about the story of Frodo Baggins and discovered how Frodo had come to be part of the story. Gandalf, the wisest wizard that walked middle earth, had said something about the strength of those with the smallest stature. I thought that perhaps, in order to claim my throne, I would need someone of a sort like that. So I came here, on my way to the Shire, to find someone to share in my adventure.”

Freesia’s eyes widened with surprise. An adventure? Please do not ask me to come!

Book vs. Movie: Why the Changes?

Let me just get on my soap box for a moment.

First I would like to point out the obvious fact:

Books and movies are two completely different forms of entertainment. Why does that matter? Well, let me tell you.

Before you can criticize the changes made to a story line when put in movie form you have to realize why this previously stated fact is important.

Book: Imagery created by you.

Movie: Imagery created by filming team.

Book: Characters imagined by you.

Movie: Characters picked from real actors (I say real because you have to realize that you can’t find an actor/actress that looks exactly like the character, especially since everyone pictures them differently).

Book: Every detail in a scene has to be explained to a tee.

Movie: Every detail has to be created and is shown in a much shorter space of time than a written out description.

Book: Takes a long time to make a point, considering it is all written out.

Movie: Long paragraphs in a book are only a few seconds in a movie.

Book: Doesn’t need too much action and adventure in order to be a good story line.

Okay, before I say this one, it needs some explaining. This is somewhat more of an opinion, but sort of not. Okay, let me try to make this make more sense.

In today’s society, a movie will not get a good audience, or a good review, or the interest of the viewers unless it has action, romance, and humor. This wasn’t the case even just a decade ago. So, that brings the next point.

Movie: Needs action, romance and humor in order to be a “good” movie.

Need an example?

The Hobbit Movie Trilogy.

Notice,

Action: Would have been there anyway.

Romance: Tauriel and Kili.

Humor: Yeah… I’m pretty sure you can all see how this applied to these movies. Potty humor, funny (and I use that term lightly) trolls, and Bombur. Yes, just Bombur, and a little bit Ori. They were the comical relief of the movies. And sadly, they weren’t even funny. More annoying really.

So, can you see now why some of the changes from books to movie were “necessary?”

You may not have liked (I could almost definitely say didn’t like) the Tauriel-Kili thing, but that in a way is our fault. All the ratings, all the viewers, everything is ruled by our (or I guess, this generation’s) inability to enjoy a good movie without these three things.

I completely understand why Peter Jackson made the changes he did. For all we know, he could have been forced (or I guess required…same thing…) to add those things. I’m not saying I liked the out come of those decisions, but it wasn’t entirely his fault. He has been in the movie business for years, he has seen the developments, the required elements that get good ratings.

And this is also why Lord of the Rings was SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much better. Because back ten some odd years ago, we didn’t have to have stupid humor. We didn’t have to watch movies that just wasted away our brains. We watched good movies.

I am also not saying that all movies today are stupid. But a lot of them are. Some very few movies (one being the Giver) actually have meaning. Even shows like Doctor Who lost their meaning. It’s all just filler time we need to waste on something other than sitting around.

I miss the good old days when I could watch a movie and think “Oh my goodness! What just happened!?” or “Wow! Mind blown!” or “I get it now!” or “Holy crap that was amazing!” or “I can totally see the symbolism in this!” Okay, okay, I’m done now.

So, next time you want to get angry at Peter Jackson because of the Hobbit movies, get angry at society first.

Chapter Three: Three Is Company-Part One

Even after Gandalf explains to Frodo that the ring is indeed the One Ring, Frodo doesn’t make any sign of leaving for the next two to three weeks. Frodo was very reluctant to go. In fact, the only thing that made it bearable was the thought that he would be following Bilbo and would be able to see him again after Frodo almost doubled his age. He thought little about the ring and the fate of it in the end.

Gandalf explains to Frodo that he is not to tell anyone he is leaving at all. Certainly not where he is going. Frodo himself doesn’t even know where he is to go. In Gandalf’s opinion, he should make for Rivendell, which Frodo would be delighted to do, and Sam even more so.

Quite a bit later, a rumor began to spread that Frodo was selling Bag End. The hobbits were uncertain why he would do so. There were many theories, of course, being hobbits and all. What’s worse is that he was selling it to the Sackville-Bagginses! But everyone had the common belief that Frodo was going back to Buckland.

After two months in Bag End, Gandalf announced he was leaving to take care of some business. He tells Frodo to stick to his plan unless Gandalf sent word for him to change them. Most importantly, he tells Frodo not to use the ring.

Time quickly passes and Frodo and Bilbo’s birthday comes. They celebrate and forget their troubles a little while. Gandalf does not come.

Interestingly, as Frodo spends his last day in Bag End, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins shows up, pridefully grasping what is now hers, and to show that Frodo did not respect her for how rude she is it says, “Frodo did not offer her any tea.” I find it funny that this is the most disrespectful thing one can do to another. Awe, the British and their tea. It’s great.

As Frodo is preparing finally to leave, he over hears Gaffer and someone with a strange voice discussing Frodo’s leave taking. Gaffer tells the person what all the hobbits had believed about Frodo going to Buckland. This makes Frodo hugely paranoid and decides not to take the main road. And thus his adventure finally begins.

Together, Frodo, Sam, and Pippin made their way on foot toward Frodo’s “new home,” where Merry is waiting.

The three hobbits walk for what seems like forever. Frodo finds himself repeating the words of Bilbo’s song, The Road Goes Ever On and On. What Frodo doesn’t realize is that it was Bilbo he heard it from. He feels as though he made it up, in a way, but he thinks that it certainly does sound like Bilbo’s rhyming.

As they continue walking, Sam says he hears a horse galloping far behind them. Frodo hopes that it is Gandalf, but he has a feeling that it is not. Because of this, Frodo suggests that they stay off the road.

The next part is almost exactly like it is in the movie adaptation. Frodo stands in the middle of the road, hesitating to get off the road as his friends are already hiding. Finally he hides with them as a huge, black horse turns the corner. When the horse and it’s hooded rider reach the spot adjacent to where the three are hiding, the rider sits quietly, making a sound as if he is sniffing.

As the rider and his horse stand there, Frodo suddenly feels a fear that he will be discovered. He finds himself thinking about the ring and fingering it. He feels tempted to use it. Bilbo had used it. So why should Frodo not use it? The rider slowly begins to trot away until it is out of sight, and Frodo’s temptation fades.

Chapter Two: The Shadow of the Past-Part Two

Gandalf continues to help Frodo understand how the ring came to him. He tells him about a people, much like hobbits, called Stoors. Of the Stoors there is a family of great wealth. A grandmother is head of the family. The most curious and inquisitive of the family is named Smeagol. He began to forget about the beauties of the sky and trees around him and began to look down, interested in roots and under water.

This in a way foreshadows what’s to come. Those who look down tend to represent looking toward the devil. We can infer that something about Smeagol in the future will come out in a not so good way. Looking down is never good.

Gandalf explains that one day Smeagol and his friend Deagol were out by the lake one day. Deagol was fishing. Suddenly a huge fish caught his line and pulled him under the water. While underneath, Deagol spots a small, shiny object. He grabs it and later discovers that it is a ring. Smeagol sees the ring and becomes instantly jealous. He pesters Deagol, trying to convince him to give the ring to him. When Deagol refuses, Smeagol grabs him by the throat and strangles him. Thus claiming the ring.

No one had ever discovered what had happened to Deagol. Smeagol had discovered the disappearing magic of the ring and began to use it for wrong. People scorned and shunned him. They began to bully him and mock him. Smeagol started gurgling in his throat so they began to call him Gollum. Everyone wanted him gone, so his grandmother kicked him out of the house.

Gollum began to fish for food with his bare hands. He ate them raw and hid in caves. One day, he saw the sun and it felt as though it was burning him. He cursed the sun, and while looking up at it, he saw the misty mountains. He decided then to go live in the shade of the mountains. He traveled by night and began burrowing his way into the heart of the mountain where he and the ring could not be discovered.

Frodo instantly recognized Gollum’s name. Frodo was surprised that Gollum, such a vile creature, could be distantly related to hobbits themselves. This knowledge leads Frodo to realize how close he is to suffering the same fate. Gandalf even says that it could have happened to anyone, even a hobbit.

Gandalf explains that Gollum still had a part of his old self in him. He didn’t entirely become Gollum, in fact it rather was a separation of personalities in him. Both Smeagol and Gollum were there.

Gollum hated and loved the ring. He would have never gotten rid of it. He couldn’t. The ring decides when it leaves. Bilbo was the first ever to choose to leave the ring. The only one for a long time. It was more than just luck that brought Bilbo to the ring. There was another power at work.

Isildur had once had the ring, and it conveniently slipped off his finger when he had been caught. The ring does what it wants. Despite all the other evidence suggesting that this ring was the one ring, the inscription in the fire alone proves it. And Gandalf only discovered that it truly was the ring while in Frodo’s house at that very moment.

Gandalf spoke with Gollum himself. He lied and played games, but some truth came of it. Gollum eventually came out of the misty mountains for the longing of the ring. Gollum figured out where Bilbo came from and meant to go after him to get his ring back. He even tried to come to the Shire, but Gandalf left his investigation for he thought he had better things to do. Which turns to be a mistake.

After Gandalf had finally spoken to Gollum, Gollum slowly made his way down to Mordor.

Gollum had hoped to find aid in getting his revenge, but was instead taken and tortured. He made a grave mistake searching for aid in the dark lands. Sauron discovered where the ring went.

Frodo panicked and was frightened. He thought it a pity that Bilbo hadn’t killed him, but Gandalf states that it was pity that stopped Bilbo from killing him. Frodo says he has no pity for Gollum. Gandalf implies that if he saw Gollum, he would change his mind. Frodo thinks Gollum deserves death. Gandalf proceeds to explain to him why he doesn’t, putting Frodo’s perspective in a new light.

Frodo simply wants to be rid of the ring, and Gandalf says getting rid of it isn’t enough. It has to be destroyed, and Frodo has to try to destroy it.

The ring was made by Sauron himself in the fires of mount doom, therefore it must be destroyed in the same fire. Frodo asks why he was chosen by the ring and Gandalf says there is no way of explaining. Frodo does not want the ring, so he offers it to Gandalf. Gandalf refuses it, stating he cannot take it from him. It tempts him too much. Taking the ring would destroy him.

Frodo hopes dearly that another bearer will soon take the ring away. Without telling Gandalf, Frodo wishes he could have gone with Bilbo. To go on a nice holiday with him. Bilbo made no mistake in choosing his heir, according to Gandalf. Finally, Gandalf explains what Frodo is to do, and that he is to do everything under the name of Underhill to avoid the use of Baggins, of which Sauron now knows.

Gandalf thinks that Frodo should not go alone. Just after he states it, he pulls Samwise Gamgee right from through the window to outside.

Sam quickly defends himself by saying he was cutting the grass. Gandalf obviously does not believe him. He believes he was eavesdropping. Sam is terrified that Gandalf will turn him into something unnatural and begs Frodo to not let him do it.

Sam explains that he listened because he couldn’t help it. Hearing about elves caused him to want so badly to see elves and he begs to be brought along to meet them. Ganalf laughs, realizing he is no threat.

Sam definitely doesn’t want Frodo to leave, but Frodo tells him that it can’t be avoided. To keep Sam from telling anyone, Frodo tells him Gandalf will turn him into a toad if he does. Seeing Sam tremble at the thought, Gandalf offers to let Sam come along, to keep Frodo in good company with a great friend. Sam becomes very excited, thinking it great he will be able to see elves. And then Sam begins to cry.

Chapter Two: The Shadow of the Past-Part One

For a long time after Bilbo left, all over Hobbiton his disappearance was discussed. Most believed he had finally cracked and gone mad. Frodo turned out to be much like Bilbo; always keeping to himself, acting strange. He continued to throw birthday parties for Bilbo, although many had presumed him dead. They all blamed Gandalf for the way Frodo and Bilbo acted. They didn’t seem to realize that Gandalf was giving them both the essential push towards a prosperous and wonderful life. If the hobbits never know evil, they will never grow to understand good.

After Bilbo left, Frodo became very distant. He spent most of his time with only three people. Often he would wander off alone, which Pippin and Merry theorized as him going off with the elves as Bilbo had. He had become more and more like Bilbo. He even showed no signs of aging as Bilbo had. This means also that Frodo would have started carrying the heavy temptation at a much younger age, but yet still old enough to be responsible, seeing as he had just become an adult.

Frodo began to wish that he had gone with Bilbo; he dreamt about mountains and lands he had never seen before. He wanted badly to see them, but part of him kept telling him it was not yet time for him to go. It is much like waiting for our turn to come to earth. Obviously, we didn’t all come at the same time, so that tells us there was some amount of time we had to wait before we came down to earth.

Quick side note:

We find out by the fact that the ring makes one invisible that something about the ring is magic. We can see through Tolkien’s stories that Sauron does not, in fact, turn invisible. Why? Because the ring doesn’t actually turn you “invisible.” It actually, essentially, pushes the wearer into the unseen “Wraith World.” Because Sauron can dwell in both worlds at once, the ring can’t put him in a world he is already in. As the wearer uses the ring, they fade more and more because of the effects the other world has on mortals.

So, with that, we can infer that simply carrying the ring could be dangerous. After all, are we to assume that just having the magical metal on a specific part of the body is the only way we are affected by magical objects? No, of course not! Touching it, carrying it, is enough to have some extent of effect on us.

This effect pushes Frodo away from others to an extent. Just as wearing it willingly with the intent to use its power pushes you into the other world, carrying it for other purposes pushes you away from your social world. This is why Frodo is so far from his friends.

The Hobbits only heard rumors of what was happening in the world. Elves were leaving, never to come back to Middle Earth. Creatures of unknown decent we heard of. Mordor was being rebuilt. It was very strange for Hobbits to even hear about Mordor. For such a far away safe haven, it is very rare for any news of Mordor to reach the ears of Hobbits. That foreshadows the story, telling us that we haven’t heard the end of Mordor in the plot line.

Next we hear a conversation involving Sam and some other Hobbits. The Shire is a place of so much ignorance that the people start to think that not even dragons-despite Bilbo’s tales-exist. They have heard a witnesses account and yet still don’t think it ever happened. This could almost be compared to how some people in real life don’t believe certain world events happened.

Take the Holocaust for example. Many people refuse to believe the Holocaust ever happened. They like to think that it was made up and there was no suffering of the Jewish people. We know that that is obviously wrong. We also know that these Hobbits are wrong about the non-existence of magical creatures. Perhaps the near to last chapter of the entire Lord of the Rings trilogy makes sense of why Tolkien would have the events of the chapter happen (which I will get to when I reach that chapter. If I forget to mention it, remind me).

Eventually, Gandalf turns up for the first time since the party. He only stays a little while and leaves again, returning occasionally to speak with Frodo. Sam sees and knows of this. I wonder what that will provoke Sam to do? Hmm. Maybe drop some eaves? Maybe, maybe.

Gandalf returns once more, one day, and speaks to Frodo about the ring. Frodo is somewhat confused at first. Gandalf told him the ring was dangerous. Frodo asks him what he means by it. Frodo is terrified as Gandalf goes on to tell him about the rings of power and how they affect mortals. He tells Frodo that those who have one for too long don’t die, but don’t grow either. They simply exist. And slowly they begin to fade into the darkness of the world they are in as they wear the ring.

Sam can be heard out cutting the grass.

Frodo asks Gandalf how much Bilbo knew of the ring. Gandalf proceeds to tell him that he knew no more than what he told Frodo. Bilbo had thought it was just a nifty little tool. He did, however, notice that it changed. It needed looking after. The ring became constantly on his mind. He hadn’t realized that the ring itself was to blame. He even noticed that the ring would change size. He had no idea what the true power of the ring was.

Gandalf explains what Bilbo had said in the last chapter. How he was “thin and stretched.” Gandalf says that it means the ring began taking control.

At this point, Gandalf still doesn’t even know if the ring really is the ring of power. There is only one last test to be sure, and Gandalf doesn’t doubt much the guess he made. Gandalf made this guess not long after Bilbo found the ring. He had acted strangely about it and even had similarities to the way Gollum had acted. There is a little bit of foreshadowing when Gandalf says, “I might perhaps have consulted Saruman the White, but something always held me back.” Now, why could that be? Why would Gandalf have a feeling he shouldn’t talk to Saruman about it?

Gandalf didn’t want to believe the ring was the One Ring. He had thought many times about the possibility. He noticed connections, but tried to justify them. Perhaps Gandalf didn’t want to believe his dear old friend was in the sort of trouble he was. Think about it like this. Think of a friend you have had for many years. Imagine they got into some stuff that seemed great to them at first, but then took a wrong turn, resulting in many complications in their life. The ring is meant to represent temptation. Maybe Gandalf didn’t want to believe that Bilbo had fallen to such a horrible temptation. Or maybe he didn’t want to have to find a way to fix it. After all, he knew how difficult it would be.

Frodo begins to worry about what the presence of the ring means for the rest of the hobbits. Gandalf says that Sauron had completely over looked hobbits. Years he has not taken notice of them. He seems to underestimate the power we each have in ourselves to have control over him and his temptations.

The last test to be sure that the ring is the one he thinks it is is to place the ring in the fire. Frodo takes out the ring and does so. The magical properties causes it to be cool upon taking it out of the fire. When the inscription appears, Gandalf relays the meaning. “one ring to rule them all and in the darkness bind them.” (This is the only part he says aloud.) He then tells the little riddle about the rest of the rings. This ring is in fact the One Ring.

Upon hearing this, Frodo becomes saddened and afraid. He doesn’t want this ring. He wishes it had never come to him. Maybe this is like us coming to earth. In heaven we were all so excited to come to earth and experience life and a body. We didn’t quite understand what it meant. All we know is that it is God’s plan and we want to be a part of it. But when we get here, we experience trials, challenges, and feel so much pain. We hadn’t expected pain to be such a terrible thing. And yet we find ourselves having to experience it. What we don’t realize at this time is that it will be for the better. It will end and we will have conquered it.

On the bright side, Sauron doesn’t have the ring. As long as the ring is in Frodo’s possession, Sauron can not have his full power. Gandalf explains what happened to the other rings. The three elves hid and have not been touched by Sauron’s power. The rings of the dwarves were all taken from them. Three were taken by Sauron, the rest were taken by dragons, which might as well be eternally lost for all the gold dragons take and care not for individual pieces. The nine, as we know, were not only taken, but used to control the men, making them into the ring wraiths.

And yet with all those rings, he still needs the one to bring him back his power. After all, he did purposefully make it so that he could have that one to control the others. One to rule them all.

We discover that Sauron is not quite as skillful and powerful as he would have them think. He hadn’t even known his ring wasn’t destroyed. This shows us that he doesn’t have the connection to the ring in order to know whether or not it is still around. The important part of this being he is not connected to the ring.

Gandalf explains how the ring came to Frodo. It was actually Elendil and Gil-galad who had been together fighting Sauron. After Elendil died, Isildur, his son, took his father’s sword and cut the ring from Sauron’s hand. He explains that Isildur kept the ring and was then killed, losing the ring into the river. The ring passed from legend, and was never thought of again.

And where the ring’s story continues can finally be put together after all of Gandalf’s research in the library of Gondor. The story is finally put together and can now be given an end.

Chapter One: An Unexpected Party-Part Two

The instant Bilbo disappears in chapter one, every single guest at the party bursts into conversation. Most of the talk was of how crazy Bilbo is. Frodo just sits and laughs quietly at the amusement of the guests.

As Frodo sits and ponders, he begins to think about Bilbo’s little trick a little harder. He realizes how much he cares for Bilbo. I like to think Frodo in that moment started to wonder what would happen to him if Bilbo really was gone. If Bilbo really had disappeared and would never return. That is what makes him realize how sad he would become if Bilbo left this world in such a quick flash as his trick.

Tolkien makes a large deal about the clothes Bilbo changes into when he returns to Bag End. He describes the nice, embroidered party clothes he removes and the old, tattered clothes that replace them. Thinking about this, ask yourself, Why would someone who has such nice and expensive things change into old, dirty clothes on such an occasion as an important birthday? No one would even change into dirty clothes on their worst day unless it was their last resort.

Tolkien explains further in a way that makes us realize that the clothes Bilbo puts on are the same as those he word on his adventures with the dwarves. Think about the symbolism behind the clothing. Bilbo had never really been one to wear expensive things and look fancy. We can tell this by the way he is constantly giving to those around him, thinking not of himself, but others. Also, it says that Bilbo rapped up his fine linen clothing and put it carefully away, this makes it seem as though he hasn’t even worn it before, he still has the packaging it came in.

The clothes he wore on his journey symbolize his old self. The part of him the was “more Took-ish.” These clothes show all the wear and tear of an adventure, of which you would never experience behind the borders of the Shire. This tells us that he is not planning to stay in the Shire, which we can also assume by the other things he was said to have gathered together upon returning to Bag End. Also, those old clothes represent his old self. Bilbo is choosing to embrace that of his past and leave what home he has already.

Bilbo soon verifies this theory himself as he converses with Gandalf. He tells Gandalf he is going on a holiday and doesn’t mean to come back.

Taking a step back for a moment: Before Gandalf shows up, Bilbo puts his ring in an envelope and sets it on the shelf, then just after he takes it out again. At this point for most people (who don’t already know the story by heart, but have read the Hobbit), we can tell that there is something about the ring that isn’t quite the same as it was in the Hobbit. Bilbo can’t seem to detach from the ring, but this could also just be a simple man who doesn’t want to separate from such a sentimental treasure.

During Bilbo’s conversation with Gandalf, we hear another famous line.

“I feel sort of stretched, Gandalf…like butter scraped over too much bread.”

Let’s analyze this a bit, shall we?

Think about it. When you take just a knife full of butter and try to spread it over your entire toast, it eventually thins out to the point where it has no point. It doesn’t give it the flavor you intended. Bilbo here could be meaning that as he goes along, spending his days in the Shire (gliding his knife across the bread), he feels that his knife is going to continue gliding through his life, never lifting itself off to obtain more butter, never adding more to his now dull life. He feels like all this time spent idling away is stretching him, making him become more and more thin as his adventurous life is left behind him. He is only spreading his butter, dragging it in circles, going no where. This is what he uses to describe why he needs to leave.

After such marvelous and terrible adventures. How can one go back to a normal life completely?

Tolkien writes in one line that, to me seems a bit humorous on his part. Gandalf tells Bilbo that no one will read his story (which we know is actually what the Hobbit book is, technically). This makes me laugh a bit, because we know that thousands of people read the Hobbit. It’s almost as if Tolkien is making a joke about how successful his book actually was. Just a random thought.

Bilbo then says that Frodo would come with him, if Bilbo asked him. But he also says that Frodo is not ready. I compare this to our existence before earth life. Not all of us are born on earth at the same time, obviously. So this represents that we will all have a chance on earth, just that some of us aren’t ready at the same time as others. Just like how on earth we don’t all progress at the same rate.

The next bit is almost word for word in the movie. Gandalf and Bilbo discuss the ring and what its fate is to be. Bilbo calls the ring his “precious” just as Gollum had. This definitely tells us something is up. The ring starts to look more and more like a poison. Or an addiction. If this ring is causing such a respectable man to become like such a sad, pathetic creature, then there is definitely something about that ring that is not right for the mind.

Bilbo and Gandalf soon agree to leave the ring with Frodo. This tells us a TON about the type of person Frodo is. They trusted him enough to leave him such a powerful and dangerous weapon. They had to have had total faith in Frodo as a person to take care of this ring. So they leave it for him (after Bilbo tries to take it with him first, of course).

Bilbo and Gandalf say their goodbyes and Bilbo is off, singing as he goes. Which song is a very deep sort of poetry. It ends with “And whither [the road goes] then? I cannot say.” This means that he has no idea where his journey is going to take him, but yet still he goes. No one knows where their road will take them, we simply have to follow and discover for ourselves where it will go.

The next day, after Frodo had discovered Bilbo left the day before (as Bilbo had told him he was planning on doing), Frodo finds that Bilbo had written out what things he owned that he was giving away. (He even gave things away to the Sackville-Bagginses!)

This chapter ends with a conversation between Frodo and Gandalf. Gandalf explains that Frodo is to soon go out into the world on a sort of small journey. They discuss what is to happen and Gandalf tells him that he will return one day to let Frodo know when it is the time to leave. And so Frodo waits until it is his time to go into the world.

Gallery of My Tolkien Creations